• Amused
  • Angry
  • Annoyed
  • Awesome
  • Bemused
  • Cocky
  • Cool
  • Crazy
  • Crying
  • Depressed
  • Down
  • Drunk
  • Embarrased
  • Enraged
  • Friendly
  • Geeky
  • Godly
  • Grumpy
  • Happy
  • Hungry
  • Innocent
  • Meh
  • Pirate
  • Poorly
  • Sad
  • Secret
  • Shy
  • Sneaky
  • Tired
  • wtf
  • Page 1 of 2 12 Last»
    Results 1 to 25 of 29
    1. #1
      S-Rank Missing Nin ~Puppet Master~'s Avatar
      Status
      ~Puppet Master~ is online now
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      The Netherlands
      Posts
      3,875
      Post Thanks / Like
      One more exam week...
       
      Crying

      Major plothole to me...

      Sorry all the Sasori related threads, but I rewatched the fight and I noticed something.
      Chiyo should've died, and with that, Sakura would also have died, I'll explain.



      As you can see, Chiyo was cut by one of Sasori's puppets, and she never took the antidote.
      Sakura said there were two antidotes, she used the first one against the Iron Sand, and Chiyo used the second one on Sakura when she was stabbed.


      Which means Chiyo should've been paralyzed either during the fight, or when Sasori stabbed Sakura.
      If she got paralyzed during the fight, Sakura would've never been able to get Sasori and she would get raped.

      If she got paralyzed when Sakura got stabbed, Sakura would die because of her situation.
      If she did take the antidote to prevent her death, Sakura would die.
      In that case, Sasori would probably still kill himself.


      Which means that Chiyo lived even though she was poisoned, with no explanation.
      Seems like a plot hole to me, or did Kishi run out of Plot no Jutsu ideas...
       
           
      Last edited by ~Puppet Master~; 10-04-2012 at 10:02 PM. Reason: Replaced 'dead' by 'paralyzed'

    2. #2
      ソロキング -Logic-'s Avatar
      Status
      -Logic- is offline
      Join Date
      May 2012
      Posts
      10,930
      Post Thanks / Like
      Itachi Solo's.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Who cares.
       
           

    3. #3
      1st Class LOVELESS's Avatar
      Status
      LOVELESS is offline
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Location
      The Lifestream
      Posts
      877
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      I too think Sakura deserved to die.
       
           

    4. #4
      イエローフラッシ Kamishini's Avatar
      Status
      Kamishini is online now
      Join Date
      Mar 2012
      Location
      War
      Posts
      8,754
      Post Thanks / Like
      四代目|Yondaime
       
      Cool

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Like Logic said who cares?
       
           

    5. #5
      Okami the butcher's Avatar
      Status
      Okami the butcher is offline
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Location
      In true Beauty
      Posts
      8,500
      Post Thanks / Like
      So many prostitutes so little
      time.
       
      Awesome

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      the poison takes three days to kill you and she died anyways because she gave Gaara a battle res which cost her life anyways plot hole filled
       
           

    6. #6
      Megamkfan's Avatar
      Status
      Megamkfan is offline
      Join Date
      Nov 2011
      Location
      In a place it never snows (Florida)
      Posts
      6,078
      Post Thanks / Like
      Katy Perry FTW!
       
      Hungry

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Wow nice catch
       
           

    7. #7
      S-Rank Missing Nin ~Puppet Master~'s Avatar
      Status
      ~Puppet Master~ is online now
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      The Netherlands
      Posts
      3,875
      Post Thanks / Like
      One more exam week...
       
      Crying

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Who cares.
      Quote Originally Posted by -Legendary- View Post
      Like Logic said who cares?
      It's an unexplained plot hole, I care.

      Quote Originally Posted by Okami the butcher View Post
      the poison takes three days to kill you and she died anyways because she gave Gaara a battle res which cost her life anyways plot hole filled
      Yes, but you get paralyzed within a minute. That's what I mean.
       
           

    8. #8
      Hacker.'s Avatar
      Status
      Hacker. is offline
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      UK
      Posts
      2,848
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      Cool

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Who cares.
      I care.
      I mean, if its just a small plothole, its still interesting to see this. Instead of troll threads
       
           

    9. #9
      Senior Member Yusuke Urameshi's Avatar
      Status
      Yusuke Urameshi is offline
      Join Date
      May 2012
      Location
      Hanging Neck Island
      Posts
      4,943
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Who cares.
      *sees thread doesn't involve Itachi* "Who cares." Jk
       
           

    10. #10
      ソロキング -Logic-'s Avatar
      Status
      -Logic- is offline
      Join Date
      May 2012
      Posts
      10,930
      Post Thanks / Like
      Itachi Solo's.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Sasori is a fodder anyway.
       
           

    11. #11
      Banned
      Status
      Mischeif Maker is offline
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Posts
      1,973
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      she did die.....remeber she gave the antidote to sakura and then she held on....sasori even said it would take 3 days to kill kankuro and the sasori fight in reality probably took an hr or 2 in the naruto vers max and then you remeber chiyo didnt have enough chakra and need to borrow narutos to save gara .....that is because the posion had her weakend

      not a plot hole at all

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Who cares.
      haha you dont care because you cant explain it be real if it was an itachi plot hole you would cry like a newborn baby
       
           

    12. #12
      Hacker.'s Avatar
      Status
      Hacker. is offline
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      UK
      Posts
      2,848
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      Cool

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Sasori is a fodder anyway.
      Itachi died twice.
      He got trolled so bad.
       
           

    13. #13
      Member
      Status
      Iruka is offline
      Join Date
      May 2011
      Posts
      560
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      The poison actually takes three days to kill someone. The only immediate effect is the pain and paralysis. This was seen when Kankuro was poisoned. Sakura even commented on how she was amazed that Chiyo was able to move despite being poisoned.
       
           

    14. #14
      S-Rank Missing Nin ~Puppet Master~'s Avatar
      Status
      ~Puppet Master~ is online now
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      The Netherlands
      Posts
      3,875
      Post Thanks / Like
      One more exam week...
       
      Crying

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      I replaced 'died' by 'paralyzed', my mistake.

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Sasori is a fodder anyway.
      Just leave this thread, you're only satisfying yourself.
       
           
      Last edited by ~Puppet Master~; 10-04-2012 at 10:03 PM.

    15. #15
      Tobirama/Mada fan (●´▽`)♡ Hipster Madara's Avatar
      Status
      Hipster Madara is online now
      Join Date
      Mar 2010
      Location
      S.Y.S.T.E.M. Something.You.Shouldn't.Trust.Ever.Man.( ̄へ ̄)
      Posts
      14,532
      Post Thanks / Like
      http://mewlar.tumblr.com/
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      they had the antidote and wasn't it mentioned that Chiyo was in fact poisoned when she healed Gaara? -__-
       
           

    16. #16
      Okami the butcher's Avatar
      Status
      Okami the butcher is offline
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Location
      In true Beauty
      Posts
      8,500
      Post Thanks / Like
      So many prostitutes so little
      time.
       
      Awesome

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by Evert131 View Post
      It's an unexplained plot hole, I care.



      Yes, but you get paralyzed within a minute. That's what I mean.
      where does it say you get paralyze within a minute?
       
           

    17. #17
      Banned
      Status
      Mischeif Maker is offline
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Posts
      1,973
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by Evert131 View Post
      I replaced 'died' by 'paralyzed', my mistake.



      Just leave this thread, you're only satisfying yourself.
      my opinion.....she is old and has bad circulation because thing like this need to circulate in the blood that or as a puppet master she may have a tolerance for it having being posioned b4

      just like how sasuke is immune to it
       
           

    18. #18
      ... Varrah's Avatar
      Status
      Varrah is offline
      Join Date
      Aug 2012
      Posts
      739
      Post Thanks / Like
      「決勝 来臨」
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Sasori is a fodder anyway.
      I'd be happy to prove you wrong...
       
           

    19. #19
      S-Rank Missing Nin ~Puppet Master~'s Avatar
      Status
      ~Puppet Master~ is online now
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      The Netherlands
      Posts
      3,875
      Post Thanks / Like
      One more exam week...
       
      Crying

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by Hipster Madara View Post
      they had the antidote and wasn't it mentioned that Chiyo was in fact poisoned when she healed Gaara? -__-
      Quote Originally Posted by Okami the butcher View Post
      where does it say you get paralyze within a minute?
      Kankuro fell down after a few minutes after being stabbed by Hiruko's tail, Sakura fell down after a few seconds after being hit by Iron Sand: World Order, so it depends on how severe the wound is, but it was definitely a bigger wound than Kankuro's so she should've fallen down in a minute.

      Quote Originally Posted by Mischeif Maker View Post
      my opinion.....she is old and has bad circulation because thing like this need to circulate in the blood that or as a puppet master she may have a tolerance for it having being posioned b4

      just like how sasuke is immune to it
      That would mean that she wouldn't need the antidote at all...
       
           

    20. #20
      Senior Member natzzz's Avatar
      Status
      natzzz is offline
      Join Date
      May 2012
      Posts
      1,705
      Post Thanks / Like
      HALF HALLOW
       
      wtf

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by -Logic- View Post
      Sasori is a fodder anyway.
      NO.
       
           

    21. #21
      -Carnage-'s Avatar
      Status
      -Carnage- is offline
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      Yes.
      Posts
      6,384
      Post Thanks / Like
      With great power, Comes great
      electricity bill.
       
      Cool



      Re: Major plothole to me...

      i thought chiyo was dying, but slowly.....
       
           

    22. #22
      Reanimation numbers's Avatar
      Status
      numbers is offline
      Join Date
      Jul 2011
      Location
      UK
      Posts
      3,597
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      I'm guessing Chiyo has a certain intolerance for it, maybe because she's so used to being around poison and working with similar tools. She did show signs of her body shutting down if you remember, it probably just took longer to circulate because she was old.

      Still a good question to raise, thanks
       
           

    23. #23
      Konohas Flasher Narutohokage7's Avatar
      Status
      Narutohokage7 is online now
      Join Date
      Apr 2012
      Location
      Chilling with Roshi, Sanji, Brook and Jiraiya at bathhouses.
      Posts
      7,066
      Post Thanks / Like
      When life gives you
      melons....you're most likely
      dyslexic
       
      Cool

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Hardly a plot hole. I believe Chiyo said to Naruto n'all when she was healing Gaara that she was gone for anyway cause of the poisen.
       
           

    24. #24
      Banned
      Status
      Mischeif Maker is offline
      Join Date
      Sep 2012
      Posts
      1,973
      Post Thanks / Like
      This user has no status.
       
      ----

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by Evert131 View Post
      Kankuro fell down after a few minutes after being stabbed by Hiruko's tail, Sakura fell down after a few seconds after being hit by Iron Sand: World Order, so it depends on how severe the wound is, but it was definitely a bigger wound than Kankuro's so she should've fallen down in a minute.



      That would mean that she wouldn't need the antidote at all...
      no it wouldnt there is a difference between resistance and immunity and sasori poision was special it said meaning she probably wasnt immune but just had a general resistance to poision meaning it takes longer to take effect but still kill in the end

      Quote Originally Posted by Narutohokage7 View Post
      Hardly a plot hole. I believe Chiyo said to Naruto n'all when she was healing Gaara that she was gone for anyway cause of the poisen.
      see this only helps prove my point as she did say she was done for meaning she did probably just have a resistance
       
           

    25. #25
      Juho- Fuuton Shoryuken KGB Kakuzu's Avatar
      Status
      KGB Kakuzu is online now
      Join Date
      Jul 2012
      Location
      In a steam room with Han....counting my money with Kakuzu....watching the stars with Hinata
      Posts
      6,164
      Post Thanks / Like
      "Akuma no Ko" Robin
       
      Innocent

      Re: Major plothole to me...

      Quote Originally Posted by Evert131 View Post
      It's an unexplained plot hole, I care.



      Yes, but you get paralyzed within a minute. That's what I mean.
      That awkward moment when you say I care and it completely blows up the arguers statement

      Yeah nice catch!!! It could be that Chiyo had some natural poision resistence, but I understand how you feel being that Kankuro went out in minutes. Who knows how much will power the old lady had
       
           

    Page 1 of 2 12 Last»

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •