[Discussion] Ranking of the Straw Hat Crew

[Lt Fresh]

So when it comes to ranking the Straw Hat crew members from strongest to weakest there isn't much difference going on in the top 3.
-Luffy
-Zoro
-Sanji

But who is next, who is the 4th, 5th and so on.
Randomly:
-Brook
-Franky
-Usopp
-Chopper
-Nami
-Robin

How would you rank them? Who is the next on the list as the strongest?
My List in order:
-Luffy
-Zoro
-Sanji
-Brook
-Franky
-Robin
-Chopper
-Usopp
-Nami

[jordan1]

-Luffy
-Zoro
-Sanji
-Robin
-Chopper
-Franky
-Brook
-Usoop
-Nami

[rikerslade]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Sanji
4. Brook
5. Franky
6. Chopper
7. Robin
8. Nami
9. Usopp

[Revol]

1.Lufyy
2.Zoro
3.Sanji
4.Franky
5.Brook
6.Robin
7.Ussop
8.Chopper
9.Nami

[jordan1]

Seriously Robin is placed in 4th not brook

[Revol]

1.Lufyy
2.Zoro
3.Sanji
4.Franky
5.Brook
6.Robin
7.Ussop
8.Chopper
9.Nami

[Yuka]

these are a list of characters who i think are the strongest,

Zoro

Luffy

Sanji

nami

chopper

[Arsenicpop]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Sanji
4. Brook
5. Robin
6. Fanky
7. Chopper
8. Ussop
9. Nami.

[Lt Fresh]

Seriously Robin is placed in 4th not brook

Why do you think Robin is stronger than Brook, just asking

[Arsenicpop]

but if Jinbe does join the strawhats as hinted he would be 3rd.

[rikerslade]

Brook would beat Robin. If Robin snaps Brook with Clutch, he can reform. His ice power would beat Robin.

[jordan1]

Why do you think Robin is stronger than Brook, just asking

Robins powers are more suitable to win a match I personally think she could easily kill sanji with clutch but anyway why you say brook is stronger? he's not even a good swordsman

[rikerslade]

but if Jinbe does join the strawhats as hinted he would be 3rd.

Naw, I think Oda will postpone Jinbei's joining till Sanji and Zoro get stronger so as the Monster Trio isn't disrupted. Also, Jinbei would probably be second, not third.

[Lt Fresh]

but if Jinbe does join the strawhats as hinted he would be 3rd.

I'm debating that for now. I feel like by the time he joins Zoro and Sanji would have increased in power to level that they would be stronger than Jinbe.

Plus adding in the fact Luffy fights the strongest enemy in each Arc while Zoro and Sanji fights the 2nd and 3rd, I don't think that formation should change. They are the deadly trio of the crew

[Lt Fresh]

Robins powers are more suitable to win a match I personally think she could easily kill sanji with clutch but anyway why you say brook is stronger? he's not even a good swordsman

Before I state my reason how far are you in the Manga?

[bladesofchaos360]

brook is easily fourth place.

[rikerslade]

Robins powers are more suitable to win a match I personally think she could easily kill sanji with clutch but anyway why you say brook is stronger? he's not even a good swordsman

The only reason Sanji won't beat Robin is because he doesn't kick women.

And Brook is a good swordsman, he just doesn't as good as others. Robin's powers won't work on him as he can reform his bones.

[jordan1]

The only reason Sanji won't beat Robin is because he doesn't kick women.

And Brook is a good swordsman, he just doesn't as good as others. Robin's powers won't work on him as he can reform his bones.

I see your point about brook but she could defineatly beat sanji

[Arsenicpop]

But there is no doubt that Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji will be the top 3. But Jinbe is still rivals Luffy at this point. Don't underestimate Brook.
His Ice attack is quite formidable, he is insanely fast, fast enough to run on water, and do not forget his music can alter ones minds. Don't forget what he did during the battle at Fishman Island, he made the other pirates hallucinate and fire their guns in the air.

[Lt Fresh]

I see your point about brook but she could defineatly beat sanji

So since they that guy conviced you about Brook I guess I can do the Sanji part.

-I doubt Sanji would lose to Robin. If he ignores the fact that she is a woman he can win this fight. Robin's power is restricted to what she can see, If she can't see Sanji she can't grab him. He is quite a fast character he has a ton of power. He can also break the very earth they stand on to throw Robin of balance and deliver a Kick that would finish her. Sanji has proven time and time again he is the 3rd strongest crewmate just by defeating the 3rd strongest enemies on rival pirate/marine teams

-If you havent caught up in the Manga don't read this part. Spoiler: Sanji has Haki, the one that hardens his body so he can inflict pain onto fruit users. This power allows him to harden any part of his body so that it becomes metal like. By doing so there is no way she can do Clutch on him.

[KGB Kakuzu]

Monster Trio

4. Robin (Not only has it been referenced that Robin is most likely the smartest member of the crew. Also her Hana Hana no mi practically makes her able to defeat anyone who is not a Logia user. Against Brook she csn break his bones which he said can cause him to be actually harmed. Against Franky she csn use her arms to close his Rocket Shoulders or close other weapon points like she did to the Pacifista. She easily beats Ussop and Nami....she has giant hands to beat Chopper. Although on theory her power should put her above Sanji, but I give Sanji the benifit of the doubt.)

5. Franky (Armor beats Brook)

6. Brook

7. Chopper

8. Ussop

9. Nami

[reizon]

luffy
zoro
sanji
robin
dont care about the rest of idiots specially nami.

[Simple Math]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Sanji
4. Franky
5. Robin
6. Brook
7. Chopper
8. Usopp
9. Nami

my list might be mistaken since im not done with all chapters yet.

[rikerslade]

It's funny how you guys blatantly ignore Oda saying Usopp will always be the weakest.

[Arsenicpop]

still always think Usopp > Nami. I just can't stand her.