[Discussion] How did Uchiha Madara give tobi the rinnegan ?

[NeedAnime]

As explained here It wasn't Tobito who gave Nagato his Rinnegan , it was Uchiha Madara. :

http://http://www.narutobase.net/forums/showthread.php?t=236705

But how ?

If he gave the eyes to him , then hashi didn't kill him and cuz of Edo Tensei we see he died at a relatively young age !

My theory is that he :Aquired Hashi's abilities but he was badly hurt
then he summons a summon or uses clone(s) to take out his ayes and deliver them to nagato.

My theory is stupid , i know , i want to hear yours.:ice:

[-S-]

The link isn't working .-.

[minato12345]

ur link does not work

[LssJBroly]

Hmm maybe
But why Nagato is the question ?

[Negative Knight]

No i think he acquired the Rinnegan after his battle which was a near death experience. Then he read the scrolls and Nagato was mentioned as a child of prophecy. He constructed Zetsu and later found Obito (maybe he used Rinne of Rebirth or Zetsu to heal him). Then he made it so that Obito would implant the eyes in Nagato just after Madara's death and revive him with Rinne of Rebirth.

[RHCP]

No i think he acquired the Rinnegan after his battle which was a near death experience. Then he read the scrolls and Nagato was mentioned as a child of prophecy. He constructed Zetsu and later found Obito (maybe he used Rinne of Rebirth or Zetsu to heal him). Then he made it so that Obito would implant the eyes in Nagato just after Madara's death and revive him with Rinne of Rebirth.

That doesn't work. Nagato is older than Obito. If you said Tobi, I wouldn't have objected.

[thegame]

Madara didn't give his eyes to nagato, he made tobito do it

[Bloodytaste]

That doesn't work. Nagato is older than Obito. If you said Tobi, I wouldn't have objected.

we still do not even know, when madara really died~ and if nagatos rinnegan is really madaras "own"~ it like when tobi said my power, uchiha madaras power~ We can only assume things, and it still possbile for Nagato to have his own Rinnegan, with some help of madara ~

[psukkar]

Madara didn't give his eyes to nagato, he made tobito do it

technically speaking if we are under the notation that tobi is obito then nagato is much older than obito. technically speaking.


so one would imagine nagato having the rinnegan frist then tobi. but hey thats assuming tobi is infact obito no strings attached if u know whaty i mean.

[Defendaga]

My best guess is that Madara lived to be around 90 - 100.
He probably just barely survived fighting Hashirama and seemingly pulled an Orochimaru.

Notice when Madara is revived, he mentions "He was able to revive me like this", implying he was obviously in some different state when he died.
http://www.mangareader.net/naruto/560/2


Many years on, he somehow activated his rinnegan, most likely something to do with the war going on at the time and transplanted them to Nagato (my guess is Nagato is somewhere between 30 - 40, as Yahiko himself died some time ago yet Choji mentions that he looks around 25 - 30).
Several years later, he came across Obito and took him in, healed (possibly with zetsu clones), trained, taught him everything he knew and left his will to Obito.

[Evidence he was alive to have known Obito]
http://www.mangareader.net/naruto/561/9