Who really killed Rin? Naruto chapter 604 discusion....

[TiddlySkydiver]

If that is the real Kakashi, and that is the real Rin, then Kakashi had a good reason for doing it.

[~Madara Uchiha~]

yah he also had reason for sealing it too he knew naruto would master the nine tails power and be able to defeat the masked man

[Prime Rib]

if it was an order then minato would do it himself. he would never let kakashi(a kid) go trough such a pain.

kakashi was a jounin, and minato could not do himself he was hokage he didnt have time just to kill rin on that mission he had other priortys, and he gave that mission to kakashi beccause of his skills of assasination and he knew rin better than anyone else

seems possible but i doubt it
cant imagine minato to say something like that lol

lol i agree with you but he is hokage he had to make that decision when he became it, that was the oath he took when he acended to protect the vilage above all else

[natzzz]

Don't make assumptions about kakashi until kishi explains what happens.

ASSUMPTIONS ARE WHAT IS REVALED TO BE THE TRUTH.ONE OF THEESE THEORY'S WILL SURELY BE THE RIGHT ONE SO THERE IS NO HARM IN POINTING OUT THE POSITIVE POINT'S OF THE THEORY ONE SUPPORT'S.AND

THAT'S NO ASSUMPTION.

[oShux]

i dont see any way in which kakashi and rin had to face yahiko.nagato situation.if the mist was gonna make some one die it would be kakshi.he's lot stronger then rin.

Maybe she's a spy then?

[natzzz]

maybe she's a spy then?

makes more sense then zetsu theory at least.

[-Haku Yuki-]

He wanted to touch her boob but forgot that he still had Chidori going.
/thread

rotflmao lol nice

[lsgteam]

look i noe its hard to believe this but, at least understand both jiriya and tsunade have said the 4th hokage dosent do things without a good reason, yes he loved his village his family and his team, but he is hokage he puts the village above all else, he saved the leaf village by sealing the 9 tails in his own son,

So u are saying that Rin got so mad that she was a danger to the village? That Minato had to order to kill a child? Dont think so

[oShux]

If that were true minato would do this himself not send a kid to do it and Rin isn't even that strong how the fk would she be a missing nin. Nice try though ( I mean that sincerely )

[Prime Rib]

So u are saying that Rin got so mad that she was a danger to the village? That Minato had to order to kill a child? Dont think so

did you not read at all on the first post? she either became a spy for another village, or became a missing ninja not long after obito "Death". those 2 things can get you killed in naruto universe

[Mischeif Maker]

that is bs if that was the case minato would have gona and brought he back and put her in jail he would never kill someone when he could save them

he sealed the fox in naruto because it was his only choice at the time because he knew naruto was gonna one day need that power to fight tobito

[Prime Rib]

If that were true minato would do this himself not send a kid to do it and Rin isn't even that strong how the fk would she be a missing nin. Nice try though ( I mean that sincerely )

First off minato became hokage after the 3rd shinobi war, he did not have time to do that mission himself, kakashi may of have been a kid but hes a JOUNIN dont forget that he is a leaf shinobi and missions come above all else, and your right rin isnt that strong, and you dont have to be strong nor weak to become a missing nin- go re read my thread i put that she could be a spy for another village which she got caught, thats why minato had kakashi assasinate her before she could leak info to other villages.

[narutodarkfox]

duh you can die for being a spy for another village or die by becoming a missing ninja isn't it obvious

[Prime Rib]

that is bs if that was the case minato would have gona and brought he back and put her in jail he would never kill someone when he could save them

he sealed the fox in naruto because it was his only choice at the time because he knew naruto was gonna one day need that power to fight tobito

Is it really Bs? he cant just jail her for the rest of her life? no thats not how it works, and he is hokage he cant give a ninja a 2nd chance when there
leaking info to other shinobi villages during war

yes he sealed the fox demon into naruto that he had hopes that one day naruto could take full controll of kurama and his power, but still that was not his only reason he did that like im trying to tell you he sealed into naruto TO SAVE THE VILLAGE, he puts the village first before his family, thats the duty of the kages

[Noddy]

That goes against the way Minato has generally been portrayed in this manga, which leads me to doubt this theory greatly.

[Prime Rib]

That goes against the way Minato has generally been portrayed in this manga, which leads me to doubt this theory greatly.

Fair enough, but i still believe minato is a good guy, but he was hokage he had to put the village saftey above all else, but if it comes down to obito revealing more on why he attack the village beccause minato orderd kakashi to kill rin

[tombadil24]

kakashi didn't want some secret information to be spoiled. they mentioned they were surrounded by other shinobi. you can tell kakashi didn't want to do kill her from his tears

[★YellowFlash1]

Kish would never destroy the reputation or Minato and Kakashi like that ... Kakashi would have refused to kill rin. Look how much he respects obito by visiting his grave everyday for hours... No way he would just go back on his word like obito's last dieing words meant nothing!

Minato was such a nice kind hearted person! Even if he was going to kill her then im sure he wouldn't send kakashi... He would of never let kakashi know about her death if it came to it!

I believe that the truth will be revealed proving that it wasn't kakashi fault or it wasn't him! Tobi will turn good and madara will get shafted then it will be time for Naruto V sasuke! :D

[rollin]

he got pissed when sasuke tried kill sakura with it

and he said chidori is not to be used against friends

there's more to what happened

[transroboball]

Think Danzo made him do it, kakashi was Anbu,maybe a member of root.

[Prime Rib]

Kish would never destroy the reputation or Minato and Kakashi like that ... Kakashi would have refused to kill rin. Look how much he respects obito by visiting his grave everyday for hours... No way he would just go back on his word like obito's last dieing words meant nothing!

Minato was such a nice kind hearted person! Even if he was going to kill her then im sure he wouldn't send kakashi... He would of never let kakashi know about her death if it came to it!

I believe that the truth will be revealed proving that it wasn't kakashi fault or it wasn't him! Tobi will turn good and madara will get shafted then it will be time for Naruto V sasuke! :D

i understand what your saying, but look how kishi turn obito into? he was a nice kid kind, and helping now hes just a killer. and kakashi couldent refused the mission beccause he would be punished for that, but look at the chapter where kakashi is surprised that obito is still alive, and how he tells obito aren't you gunna blame me? obito says no beccause its the world that we live in, to further plot this, is that the reason minato had kakashi do it was beccause kakashi was the only one who could catch her off guard thats why.

Have a open mind, why do you think obito tryed to destroy the leaf village? and try to kill his former sensei and his newborn son? its revenge for what he did, minato is a good guy i believe that to but people still dont understand that the kages of each village have to make sacrifices to keep there villages saftey alive, for a perfect example, garra Dad he put a monster into his own son when he was born just like minato did with naruto, there motives were both the same to protect there villages, that is another reason why people must understand is that kakashi didnt murder rin he didnt kill her out of anger or hate, its beccause he was orderd to kill her for what she did which will be explain, its his duty

[Prime Rib]

Think Danzo made him do it, kakashi was Anbu,maybe a member of root.

thought so to was gunna make a theory on that but no cause kakashi was only like 14-16 when he joined anbu, in the root danzo has kids grow up from a early young age and then kill each other, plus if kakashi were in root he would and still has the mark on his tounge, not only that you cant leave root without dieing, its blood in or blood out

[transroboball]

thought so to was gunna make a theory on that but no cause kakashi was only like 14-16 when he joined anbu, in the root danzo has kids grow up from a early young age and then kill each other, plus if kakashi were in root he would and still has the mark on his tounge, not only that you cant leave root without dieing, its blood in or blood out

Good point but we never saw Kakashi's tounge, and maybe Danzo made an exception in Kakashi case cause he's the son of the White Fang.

[★YellowFlash1]

i understand what your saying, but look how kishi turn obito into? he was a nice kid kind, and helping now hes just a killer. and kakashi couldent refused the mission beccause he would be punished for that, but look at the chapter where kakashi is surprised that obito is still alive, and how he tells obito aren't you gunna blame me? obito says no beccause its the world that we live in, to further plot this, is that the reason minato had kakashi do it was beccause kakashi was the only one who could catch her off guard thats why.



Have a open mind, why do you think obito tryed to destroy the leaf village? and try to kill his former sensei and his newborn son? its revenge for what he did, minato is a good guy i believe that to but people still dont understand that the kages of each village have to make sacrifices to keep there villages saftey alive, for a perfect example, garra Dad he put a monster into his own son when he was born just like minato did with naruto, there motives were both the same to protect there villages, that is another reason why people must understand is that kakashi didnt murder rin he didnt kill her out of anger or hate, its beccause he was orderd to kill her for what she did which will be explain, its his duty

I understand what your saying bro :D

I think the reason that he went bad was the fact that it shows how such a young kid with dreams can change ... It show's that madara is one twisted mofo .. I understand that it could happen but i doubt it. I don't see kish building up such a big reputation to just destroy it for nothing!

It wouldn't make sense for him to destroy two main character that are dearly loved. Although, I wouldn't put it past him, i wouldn't be surprised if he did tbh.... would just show how much he loved the uchihas.

[Prime Rib]

Good point but we never saw Kakashi's tounge, and maybe Danzo made an exception in Kakashi case cause he's the son of the White Fang.

true but heres another fact kakashi was the mentor of yamato when he was in anbu, and yamato isnt in root