[Discussion] Kabuto made Madara young but Edo Tensei restored his Rinnegan vs Sharingan?

[★Gyakusetsu]

We see Madara in 606 disconnect from GM life support and at that time should have died with a Sharingan. Depending on your belief of how ET works shouldn't Madara have been revived in the state he was in at death (ex:Nagato, Chiyo, Hanzou) but wait he has the Rinnegan and is also young. Now, many folks believe Kabuto restored his youth. Fine, what about the Rinnegan? That's just how ET works. Fine, what about Nagato's depleted form. Why would Kishimoto make it this complex. Until the war only Orochimaru had used ET there is no reason why Kishimoto would need to do it this way. He could have easily made Edo Tensei restore the individual to prime abilities, period. There must be another reason for this. Any theories?

[Okami the butcher]

he was restored to his prime which included his Rinnegan remember Kabuto's mastery of the Edo tensei is far better then Orochimaru's and Tobirama's

[Sharruk]

he was restored to his prime which included his Rinnegan remember Kabuto's mastery of the Edo tensei is far better then Orochimaru's and Tobirama's

this

[-Carnage-]

what Okami the butcher said....

[DeadManWonderLand]

this

double this ^^ thread maker your making it more complicated then it needs to be (: He took the old rinnegan madara and converted him to his prime how i don't know

[Lunir]

he was restored to his prime which included his Rinnegan remember Kabuto's mastery of the Edo tensei is far better then Orochimaru's and Tobirama's

Then why not do the same with Nagato, arguably his second best ET summon which was only defeated due to the limitations of his physique.

Personally I think Kishi is just horrible with plot holes.

[Hipster Madara]

Kishi confused everything with nagato.

[★Gyakusetsu]

he was restored to his prime which included his Rinnegan remember Kabuto's mastery of the Edo tensei is far better then Orochimaru's and Tobirama's

And yet he had to ask Madara if he survived his battle with Hashirama and he didn't fix Nagato's legs and chakra depletion, but aside from that why would the author choose to do it this way?

[Nazivon]

This thread again -.-

It's said that Kabuto made Madara at his prime body but with Rinnegan. It's not so hard to understand is it?

[narutodarkfox]

wow i didn't know that

[serpiente clan]

close this crapp broky

[★Gyakusetsu]

[MplQUOTEeadManWonderLand;8851698]double this ^^ thread maker your making it more complicated then it needs to be (: He took the old rinnegan madara and converted him to his prime how i don't know[/QUOTE]

I'm making it complex? Read what I wrote.

[Odd One]

What? As i remember this was explained in the manga very well.

[ShinobiMu]

there is your answer!

[ShinobiMu]

he was restored to his prime which included his Rinnegan remember Kabuto's mastery of the Edo tensei is far better then Orochimaru's and Tobirama's

there is your answer!

[Samisa]

I have a question how did kabuto get madaras body when madara was hidden in his underground place and we know obito didnt tell him because he was shocked that kabuto had madara

[★Gyakusetsu]

there is your answer!

Sigh, you either didn't read it or didn't understand it.

[Missing Nin Uzumaki RZA]

nagato my have been brought back all bonny and stuff but he was able to regain his power once he absorbed bee's cakara and that made him stronger than he was when he fought naruto..

[WindStyleCXR]

this

read here

[htmwall]

don't overthink,it's plot no jutsu's biggest strike
you see everyone was brought at his death state except madara.
conclusion: plot no jutsu

[romeboii]

its obvious the edo tensei brings people back in the prime of there power and nagato really started using his true power when yahiko died and he attached him self to the GM before that he was holding back so he never fough at his full power not attached to the GM so he would come back at his most powerful state when he was fighting threw the six paths of pain

[htmwall]

its obvious the edo tensei brings people back in the prime of there power and nagato really started using his true power when yahiko died and he attached him self to the GM before that he was holding back so he never fough at his full power not attached to the GM so he would come back at his most powerful state when he was fighting threw the six paths of pain

so nagato's prime is crippled,seems legit

[★Gyakusetsu]

don't overthink,it's plot no jutsu's biggest strike
you see everyone was brought at his death state except madara.
conclusion: plot no jutsu

How does that serve the plot other than to make you question the timeline? If the author wants you to question the timeline there must be a reason. How does that reason advance the storyline?

[ltachl]

He used Senju DNA to restore his youth.

[Draxus]

Ok I'll explain, I think a lot of people don't get what you mean so I'll take a shot

Orochimaru and Kabuto brought back Madara initially as his old dude self, then they added (more) hashirama DNA and made him younger. That's why he has rennigan, they didn't just bring back 30 year old Madara. It's 90-120 year old madara with some hashi-rejuvenation cream.