Uchiha Obito was never a liar! He hates them; how could he be one himself?

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

Obito to Kisame: "This world holds nothing but lies"

Obito is a man who has a deep sense of loathing for liars and the act of lying itself! There is proof of this:

The reason he wants to put the world that exists, to sleep, change its fate with an incredible; universal Genjutsu, is that he doesn't believe the truths of this world anymore.

Although I am certain that Kakashi tried his very best, the one promise that Kakashi made to Obito, in exchange for his own life; and the greatest weapon in his arsenal, the Sharingan, was that he would protect Rin, the person Obito cared about the most. Circumstances might not have been on Kakashis side, and due to very bad luck, Kakashi could not keep that promise to a friend that sacrificed everything for him.

To Uchiha Obito, who survived, this was betrayal of the highest order...........a lie; a lie that demolished his faith in the existing shinobi world.

You simply do not break your promises to an Uchiha, especially one who sacrificed his own life for yours.


So how can someone like Obito; who absolutely despises liars and lies alike, take up the role of one himself?

The answer lies.......in the power of the name! It was his job; a job given to him by the man who originally owned that name. Uchiha Madara gave him that title, until such time as he would be revived, Uchiha Obito would fulfill that roll.

He did it perfectly! Almost too convincingly; when I looked upon Obito after his mask had come off, I could not believe it nor accept it for a time. Even as Edo Madara had already left his coffin, I still kept believing that the man behind the mask was still some form of Uchiha Madara. That is how good he was at his job!

So fellow NBers......do not think of his grand charade as a lie! He was simply fulfilling his duty. A duty left to him by the man who showed him the true power of the Uchiha clan and the things that could be accomplished with that power.


After the first few posts, I realised most people won't even get this thread, they see things only as one or the other, right or wrong, good or evil...truth or lies. For you to understand me....you must look beyond those things.

[megaamine]

[★YellowFlash1]

haha Took the words right out of my mouth, i was just about to post the exact same thing !!

[★Simple Math]

didn't he lie saying he was Madara?
didn't he lie sayong he gave Nagato rinnegan?
didn't he lie to Sasuke about the konoha attack?

wheter if it was his job or not, he still lied.

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

didn't he lie saying he was Madara?
didn't he lie sayong he gave Nagato rinnegan?
didn't he lie to Sasuke about the konoha attack?

wheter if it was his job or not, he still lied.

He was Uchiha Madara at the time.

[Abon]

Man TBT, he the biggest liar in the manga :D

[Mannequin]

As half obito fan i couldn't agree more, You have a valid point of view...

[★Simple Math]

He was Uchiha Madara at the time.

or was he uchiha Obito under the mask?

even if he had good reasons to lie, he still lied. that's my point.

[-S-]

He gave up on this reality before he took the alias of Uchiha Madara.

Why should he care about lying to the shinobi world?

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

or was he uchiha Obito under the mask?

even if he had good reasons to lie, he still lied. that's my point.

For you and others like you, I edited the thread.

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

As half obito fan i couldn't agree more, You have a valid point of view...

Thanks

[★YellowFlash1]

He was Uchiha Madara at the time.

He wasn't madara uchiha at all, calling your self madara doesn't mean your madara...

That's like me going around calling myself Bob, doesn't mean i'm bob. I'm david :D

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

He wasn't madara uchiha at all, calling your self madara doesn't mean your madara...

That's like me going around calling myself Bob, doesn't mean i'm bob. I'm david :D

You don't get it, too immature.....

[Narukarin16]

There's only one answer, Obito has personality disorder.

[megaamine]

He was Uchiha Madara at the time.

What????

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

There's only one answer, Obito has personality disorder.

!

[Hipster Madara]

was going to say that

[Zetsu Nara]

he is a big lier, yeah he is a good actors of using other identity, but he is the most crying baby ever from uchiha's clan, same place with sasuke!!

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

he is a big lier, yeah he is a good actors of using other identity, but he is the most crying baby ever from uchiha's clan, same place with sasuke!!

Ok great....

[NaruGoku]

well, it is arguable, but i understand ur point. Obito, by his very nature, is probably not a liar. His deception of others was a battle strategy, and besides that he wasnt lying completely--he may not have been Madara, but he was certainly Madara's proxy. he paraded around as Madara in order to be able to fulfill his and Madara's ambition and it was--as you stated--under orders. Comparatively, i know a man who used to be a sniper in the army. he killed many men as a sniper, but one could hardly say he's a murderer.

On the other hand, he's lost all he ever cared for and he is now a freaking madman and i don't think he has anything against lying. He's pretty much a psycho now with no care for anything. So, even if your view is that Obito "didn't" lie, that doesn't mean he "wouldn't" lie or that he has anything against it...

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Sorry man but Obito is the biggest lying in this series, that's his character and how he achieves what he wants.

He told Nagato that he awakened the rinnegan because he is the "Chosen one" to bring peace - That was to sweeten up Nagato
He told sasuke the nine tails attack was just a "natural disaster" - That was to keep sasuke on his side because he knows it was actually him

But I know that's part of his character and I love it he's so deceptive. Ahh Obito

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

well, it is arguable, but i understand ur point. Obito, by his very nature, is probably not a liar. His deception of others was a battle strategy, and besides that he wasnt lying completely--he may not have been Madara, but he was certainly Madara's proxy. he paraded around as Madara in order to be able to fulfill his and Madara's ambition and it was--as you stated--under orders. Comparatively, i know a man who used to be a sniper in the army. he killed many men as a sniper, but one could hardly say he's a murderer.

On the other hand, he's lost all he ever cared for and he is now a freaking madman and i don't think he has anything against lying. He's pretty much a psycho now with no care for anything. So, even if your view is that Obito "didn't" lie, that doesn't mean he "wouldn't" lie or that he has anything against it...

This guy gets it ^ Pay heed people

In response, when has Obito ever lied as Uchiha Obito?

As Uchiha Madara, everything he said....was the truth. That is fact.

[Piratefish]

I like this. Personality studies, when well-made, are always interesting, so good job and many interesting points raised.

I particularly liked the "He was Uchiha Madara" bit, and it makes a lot of sense. I believe Madara may have been behind Obito's decision to take his name (and reputation) to smooth everything over. I can see him waiting to die until he'd passed on his legacy to someone: "Obito. Take my name, my fan, my armor. Take everything I was and build a better world with it."

But yeah, lies broke Obito. At one point in his life a lie made him reconsider everything in his world-view.

At one point in his life a lie made him reconsider everything in his world-view.

He certainly seems fairly free in the morality of lying after Rin's death.

[iSpeak the Truth -in detention-]

I like this. Personality studies, when well-made, are always interesting, so good job and many interesting points raised.

I particularly liked the "He was Uchiha Madara" bit, and it makes a lot of sense. I believe Madara may have been behind Obito's decision to take his name (and reputation) to smooth everything over. I can see him waiting to die until he'd passed on his legacy to someone: "Obito. Take my name, my fan, my armor. Take everything I was and build a better world with it."

But yeah, lies broke Obito. At one point in his life a lie made him reconsider everything in his world-view.

At one point in his life a lie made him reconsider everything in his world-view.

He certainly seems fairly free in the morality of lying after Rin's death.

You raise great points of your own! It is a bit sad that only a few intellectuals can truly understand my views. Thank you!

[Piratefish]

You raise great points of your own! It is a bit sad that only a few intellectuals can truly understand my views. Thank you!

Thanks to you too. Keep up the good work!