Results 1 to 4 of 4
  1. #1
    Sydney's Halo Grim's Avatar
    Status
    Grim is offline
    Gender
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    4,453
    In a society that has
    destroyed all adventure, the
    only adventure left is to
    destroy society
     



    Isshin - Uncle Shiba ?


    Kubo said that all the bloodlines would become clear. We are now starting to see the beginning of that. So who could be this "uncle" Shiba? We all know who would make the most sense but you never know what Kubo could pull with people being related.
    The uncle being Isshin has big plot holes that needs to be filled in before this turns out to be true.

    Isshin facts about:

    1. Isshin has a captain like haori but its completely different from gotei 13 captain or Royal Guard
    2. Isshin has been hiding information regarding the Kurosaki family from Ichigo
    3. Isshin's zan name is "Engetsu"
    4. Isshin's zan ability (or what has been shown) is Getsuga Tensho

    5. No Gotei 13 captain (other than Aizen and Urahara) has yet to make a connection between Ichigo and Isshin via -

    a. Kurosaki name
    b. Zan name (Zangetsu/Tensa Zangetsu/Engetsu)
    c. Zan ability (Getsuga Tensho)

    However these points can be countered if -

    a. Isshin's surname is not "Kurosaki" but something else e.g Shiba
    b. Isshin's true zan ability is not Getsuga Tensho
    c. Isshin lied to Ichigo about his zan name



    Now the fact number 5 is the main problem with the theory Kukaku is referring to Isshin as uncle (although there are loop holes). As of now no one in SS has made the connection between Ichigo and Isshin. This hold true for Yamaji (the oldest shinigami to date by appearance). He has seen Ichigo do a Getsuga Tensho in FKT, and if Isshin served as a captain under Yamaji in the last 1000 years (or in the original divisions 1000+), then Yamaji of all people should have made the connection.

    Then there are other who should have made the connection -

    - Sasakibe, who was alive and well in FKT (guarding the barrier) and thus should have seen Isshin during the fight
    - Unohana, who was alive and well in FKT (healing) and thus should have seen sensed Isshin's reiatsu
    - Every injured captain (ranging from "young" Hitsugaya to "mid" Shinji to "Older" Shunsui) would have been conscious (as Aizen puts it), hence should have seen Isshin or felt his reiatsu

    What this proves is neither Yamaji, Sasakibe, Unohana, Shunsui etc know Isshin at all although the loop hole is they have seen Isshin, but he had a different surname, didn't real his zan power or even his zan name and hid his reiatsu from them. This sounds farfetched but possible.

    or

    Isshin was from the Royal Palace either as a Royal, or as a EX-Royal Guard (who probably left 1000+ years ago even before gotei 13 was formed). As a RG, if it was within the last 1000 years, he would have had to come down to SS once or twice (seeing as by Shunsui's word they did) thus other captains should have seen Isshin. Although the loop hole again would be - they have seen Isshin, but he had a different surname, didn't real his zan power or even his zan name and hid his reiatsu from them.

    So is -

    EX-Royal Guard theory possible

    Yes, but makes no sense why did he leave or even how without anyone capturing Isshin. Although this would mean Isshin meet Ichigo's mother "Masaki" (Bach's daughter) in real word 16 years ago at the very least. However it makes no sense to me what was Bach's daughter doing in the real world, or why wasn't she in the same time limit dilemma as Bach and VR is.

    Royal theory possible

    If Isshin is a Royal how would Isshin be related to a Shiba!? The only loop hole in this would be if Kaien parent was actually Isshin's sibiling (older or younger) who set up the Shiba clan after leaving the Royal Palace 1000+ years ago. Therefore Shiba's are in fact Kurosaki's and not the other way around. Only problem with this is why does Kaien have a different zan compared to Ichigo and Isshin?

    As of now all the theories I've put is Isshin is blood related to the Shiba. However its also possible he married into the Shiba family except it makes no sense. Ichigo is partly human (or we are lead to believe he is) hence one of Ichigo's parent have to be human (Normal or Quincy or Fullbring).

    Thus theories would involve -

    Theory 1:

    Bach (a Quincy) married SK's daughter thus Isshin was born. Isshin married a Shiba (Maskai) and this Ichigo was born. Ichigo gained his Quincy power through Bach (grandfather) and shinigami power through SK's daughter (grandmother).

    Theory 2:

    Kaien's parent (head of Shiba clan), Isshin and Maskai are sibling. Masaki one way or another (say captured by VR) meet Bach and had Ichigo. However Maskai left with Ichigo to the real world due to Bach's ill nature and Isshin (her brother) adopted him.

    Theory 3:

    Kaien's parent (head of Shiba clan), Isshin and Bach are sibling. Bach ditched the family 1000+ years ago and say one way or another joined the Quincy - for example by saving a Quincy from hollow attack. He then gained Quincy power and when the shinigami turned on the Quincy fraught back since in his view the SS is being unjust. And 15 years ago, he had a son with a Quincy women thus Ichigo was born with pure Quincy blood (and family shinigami genetics passed on). However the Quincy women realized her son would be in danger of being killed by SS, and certainly will if he follows in Bach's footstep. Thus she escaped with Ichigo and came to the real world. Isshin found her and took Ichigo in due to being his nephew.


    Whats true, and Kukaku's words point out, is uncle isn't fond of the Royal palace (and most likely the SK) for a reason unknown to us and/or would be sad because Ichigo will find something about said uncle that relate to the Royal Palace. Thus we can conclude said Uncle is a Ex-RG or has royal ties.

    However I seriously doubt Ichigo is going to lose sleep if he turns out to be related to the Shiba clan (or even Soul King) via Isshin. There is something Isshin is still hiding regarding Ichigo's birth (Maskai being a Quincy wouldn't be shocking enough unless she was killed by Shinigami side). I will stick to the notion either Isshin and/or Maskai isn't Ichigo's biological parents until proven otherwise. Thats the only thing that would shake Ichigo down to his core and polarize him again SS.

    At this moment in time Ichigo's loyalty is the main factor in this war and Tite has to display some sort of crisis within Ichigo.

    Credo to Bliz >> :shrug:
     
         

  2. #2
    Rojuro's Avatar
    Status
    Rojuro is online now
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    11,694
    Location
    Soul academy
    R.I.P Big Z you'll be missed!
     

    Re: Isshin - Uncle Shiba ?

    Nice info and research.
     
         

  3. #3
    Senior Member TheHokage's Avatar
    Status
    TheHokage is offline
    Gender
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    2,794
    An opinion is not a fact...
     

    Re: Isshin - Uncle Shiba ?

    Well there's a lot of good info there but I think you could rule Masaki being a Shiba out, same with JuhaBach being Ichigo's 'true' father.

    As for Kaien, if Isshin is his uncle it isn't that much of a surprise that Kaien doesn't have the same Zanpaktou type as a Zanpaktou is a manifested form of the soul, so anyone's could be different really, but personally I think it's Kubo's way of showing Ichigo and Isshin's connection as in father and son.

    Now I've said for a while that I think Isshin was a part of 0 squad...also I think some captains have made the connection but have most likely chosen to hide it the same way they did with Ichigo's true reason to have a substitute license...but let's say I'm wrong and they haven't two reason huh either the captains don't remember (Unlikely) or they have never seen Isshin before...meaning he wasn't born in normal Soul society perhaps he was born in the kings realm (Also unlikely but hey)

    Now though the reason I truly believe Juha isn't Ichigo's father is based on both Karin and Yuzu, they are both Isshin's daughters no doubt they have the same problems Ichigo had before he had his Shinigami powers awakened they can see ghosts and interact with them Yuzu not as much but she can see them.

    Now remember this Aizen... recognized Isshin, now that does ask questions.

    So here's what I really think...I believe both Isshin and Masaki are a lot older than they have been portrayed so far, met during the or after the Quincy annihilation...fell in love, etc, Juha found out tried to stop them but Isshin was forced to use the Final Getsuga Tenshou and lost his powers however was able to escape. Now though I can't remember but I don't think Quincies can use their abilities without the cross bracelet can they or some form of chain anyway I believe they hold another purpose similar to that of Ichigo's substitute badge and it monitors Quincies, and I believe Masaki threw hers away getting camouflaged from the Quincies of course I believe Urahara helped to a lot too.
     
         

  4. #4
    Member KiraGirl K's Avatar
    Status
    KiraGirl K is offline
    Gender
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    896
    This user has no status.
     

    Re: Isshin - Uncle Shiba ?

    I've read this thread already some days before... but still : WOW!
    You guys at Bleach section are all so awesome!!!
    :worshippy:

    The ideas here make absolutely sense but still:
    I have absolutely no idea how this will be going on.
    There are still too many info I need to sort aus.

    I think at the moment so many windows are open how this story will go on!
    For each theory we have there are too many variables to consider... and all people here make valid points.
    :confused::shrug::silly:

    Thanks to the Thread Maker for sorting at least this one out and the guy above me to write a nice reply, too.
     
         

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •