More overrated: Itachi or Minato?

[Koha]

minato gave the power to naruto to end madara tobi and the jubii

z ... I don't see that, I see an entire army plus Naruto taking on Madara, Obito, & the Juubi. xD

[BloodSeed]

z ... I don't see that, I see an entire army plus Naruto taking on Madara, Obito, & the Juubi. xD

if it wasnt for naruto's clones almost all of them are dead

[AfflictionCause]

I think Minato is more overated than Itachi.

[The Alchemist]

Minato. We've seen what Itachi could do but not what Minato could really do so it's all speculation when it comes to him.

[TheRealAkatsukiLeader]

I'd say Hashirama is the most over-rated mofo on the base.

OT: Minato.

[Koha]

if it wasnt for naruto's clones almost all of them are dead

Naruto would also be dead, Kurama's out of chakra. z

[Fmafh305]

Ill have to say Minato

[Drakengard]

Really though, Minato's been praised since Part 1. Kakashi still compared BM Naruto to Minato the first time he saw his new form. You're not always supposed to use feats only (and especially in this case since we haven't got much focus on Minato, but even then he was still spectacular). If you continue with that logic then of course people are going to be disappointed by things like Hanzo's showing.

[ntel]

They are both overrated..like Itachi's 'One shot with Tsukuyomi instant win' or 'Minato's FTG teleport tag instant win'

[YellowFang]

Neither of them but Sasuke sure is...

[Typhon Uchiha]

This was just asking to go to hottest threads...

[killerman82]

Minato because we haven't seen all of his skills yet so its really not safe to judge. People still overrate him though.
Itachi has shown us he is clever and he is powerful.

[BloodSeed]

Naruto would also be dead, Kurama's out of chakra. z

youre forgeting that the main character of the show is naruto not your lord sasuke. so naruto will not die untill he finish the job

[sage22]

Everyone overrates and underate certain characters. But truth be told itachi is the 2nd strongest uchiha and both are top 10 character.

[TobisPawn]

On this forum? Tough to say. You have people say Minato can beat Edo Madara, Obito (current), Hashirama, etc. yet you also have butthurt fans in denial claim that Sasuke hasn't surpassed Itachi...

[T Bogard]

Itachi by far. I can't believe the amount of retarded fanboy who think Itachi is even close to Minato's level

[minator93]

LOL'd

Every Itachi fanboy entered just to say Minato is overrated :rofl:

If you have been on this forum as longer as I have its clear as a day that Itachi is more overrated. My sig says it all

The only other character that is more overrated than Itachi is Sasuke

[sage22]

On this forum? Tough to say. You have people say Minato can beat Edo Madara, Obito (current), Hashirama, etc. yet you also have butthurt fans in denial claim that Sasuke hasn't surpassed Itachi...

How has sasuke surpassed itachi

[minator93]

Itachi by far. I can't believe the amount of retarded fanboy who think Itachi is even close to Minato's level

Yeah, people make fail-threads about it

[Sasuke Uchiha]

I believe that Itachi IS stronger then Minato therefore Itachi does have the right to be overrated. Yet Minato is just as if not more overrated as Itachi

[hatake89]

Minato fanboys say Itachi.
Itachi fanboys say Minato.
I say both are about equal in overratedness with Itachi a but higher than Minato.

[mrcrazyboyravi]

I came up with few of Itachi's feat

feat 1. Itachi massacred his whole clan
false bcoz Tobi also helped to wipe out the entire clan who were sleeping at night.

feats 2. Itachi one shotted orochimaru and deidara
plausible but since a girl slapping and embarrasing a boy dont mean girl can defeat a boy similarly itachi just puting oro and deidara in genjutsu and mocking them dont mean he has defeated them .

feats 3. Itachi can spam amatersu and susanoo all day long
lolz . he can hold them on for even some minutes let alone chase his opponent with it

feats 4. Itachi planned his death.
Itachi died in battle due to exhaustion .Itachi himself vowed that if sasuke wasnt strong enough then he would be more than happy to kill him himself.Itachi threw everything amatersu, tsukuyomi , susanoo at sasuke and still sasuke came in top.

feats 5.Edo itachi stopped kabuto
this is the most hillarious point bcoz edo itachi is completely another being.He is like a ghost and all thing that he achieved by edo should not be included in itachi's corner.

so it seems like itachi has achieved nothing at all in his life time. Only thing he has achieved in his life are mistakes and failed plans.

like getting to kill his own parents
being a slave of danzou for his entire life
having to torture his own brother
destined to live like miserable , outcast
having to witness his brother he saved ,to go on destroying the village he loved the most
sick of deseases
etc etc and the list goes on

so it proves he is a total shit and garbage

[mrcrazyboyravi]

Itachi has earned his hype.

Genjutsu One shoting- Orochimaru [ full power ], Deidera , Kakashi, Kisame,

Saved Current Naruto and Bee from being soloed by nagato.

[IMG]http://www.google.com/imgres?q=nagato+solo+naruto&um=1&hl=en&tbo=d&sig=1 04063339384660480905&biw=1366&bih=643&tbm=isch&tbn id=kg1cLQ35VQmX0M:&imgrefurl=http://www.*****************/showthread.php%3Ft%3D857873&docid=RI1ev3Gh-ZmTCM&imgurl=http://images.wikia.com/naruto/es/images/f/f6/Nagato_inmoviliza_a_B.png&w=600&h=480&ei=aTfFUMWYG IW-8ATR1YGYAQ&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=553&vpy=125&dur=3989 &hovh=201&hovw=251&tx=137&ty=108&page=1&tbnh=147&t bnw=181&start=0&ndsp=23&ved=1t:429,r:4,s:0,i:95[/IMG]

Sealed nagato






Minato has to but, his fans think he can beat a uchiha with a Susanno.

all the highlighted part are accomplished by Edo Itachi and u cant add them in feats of real life itachi.

and also what's the point of itachi putting orochimaru in genjutsu when he actually cant kill him. itachi sealed oro, he tuskuyomied him, cut oro's hand but for what. Orochimaru is still alive , active making plans while itachi is already dead . which proves Orochimaru >>>>>>> itachi. end of chapter

[mrcrazyboyravi]

Minato because we haven't seen all of his skills yet so its really not safe to judge. People still overrate him though.
Itachi has shown us he is clever and he is powerful.

Itachi is sure cleaver enough to get his own parents and clansmen killed .
Itachi is sure cleaver enough to let his brother alive which is creating troubles for konoha, the village he loved most
Itachi is sure cleaver enough not to know true identity of Tobi and being his pawn in Akatsuki helping him accomplish the world domination plan
Itachi in his whole life only killed his own villagers and stayed alive and still his fanboys says he is the best. wtf

[AlexM123]

Sasuke is more overrated than the two of them combined. I mean really ever since he got EMS all the fanboys/girls r like "oh sasuke is really God now. He was practically God before, but now it's true. Now he can solo Edo Madara NO diff and if Minato were alive Sasuke would solo him too." REALLY! I MEAN ****ING REALLY!? Sasuke's lost damn near every 1 on 1 fight and people still act like he's so freaking great WELL HE'S NOT!

OT, as much as i like them, I would say that they are both equally overrated. With Itachi, he did show a myriad of abilities and showed that he was a very powerful ninja, but his extremely poor stamina would inevitably cause him to lose any prolonged match. As for Minato, HE ONLY HAS TWO TECHNIQUES! Supposedly to be Hokage you have to know at least 1000 jutsu but he only uses two! Talk about spam. I think they are both equally overrated because people give them abilities that they don't have (this happens out the @ss with Sasuke) and make it seem like they are stronger than what they are.