Why do people criticize Kishi?

[vVTensaZangetsuVv]

It his manga, he writes it how he wants to. People say that he should do this different and that different, and not making Obito Tobi, SHUT UP HES THE WRITER DONT LIKE IT READ ANOTHER MANGA

I think that he is doing a wonderful job at writing, every chapter lately is wonderful and full of action in my eyes

[PretaPath]

You got to admit that he ****ed up his manga on many levels, have you ever heard of freedom of speech? There's nothing wrong about criticizing.

[theRPGdude]

I seen this thread a bunch of times I can be almost certain that this is a copy.

[MrSimple]

Complaining about the complainers we meet again?

[vVTensaZangetsuVv]

You got to admit that he ****ed up his manga on many levels, have you ever heard of freedom of speech? There's nothing wrong about criticizing.

why read it if you are going to criticize it?

[PretaPath]

why read it if you are going to criticize it?

Just because I criticize some aspect of it does it mean that I hate the manga as a whole? No.

[SpiderRider89]

Kishi made some stupid decisions but that doesn't mean we should stop reading. You contradict yourself by making this thread.

[vVTensaZangetsuVv]

Kishi made some stupid decisions but that doesn't mean we should stop reading. You contradict yourself by making thus thread.

no im saying if you are going to criticizing it every step of the way why read

[Paintry4]

Hey man those people are criticized who are liable to criticize,as are we ever criticized? No coz we're not that high level people. Those pop stars,superstars,political leaders are criticized coz they are of high level so kishi is. Gotta it?

[Izuna Kakashi Senju]

Some people critize him because of the decisions he has made in the manga such as Obito being Tobi and how he hypes up charaters such as Hashirama but we never get to see him fight, but overall I think he is a terrific writer and without him there would be no Naruto.

[★-Punk-]

You got to admit that he ****ed up his manga on many levels, have you ever heard of freedom of speech? There's nothing wrong about criticizing.

exactly , i criticize if i want to , i cant stop reading cause i've invested all this time already

[enuzuki]

It his manga, he writes it how he wants to. People say that he should do this different and that different, and not making Obito Tobi, SHUT UP HES THE WRITER DONT LIKE IT READ ANOTHER MANGA

I think that he is doing a wonderful job at writing, every chapter lately is wonderful and full of action in my eyes

Saying you shouldn't criticize something, is like saying you can't praise it. It's the peoples opinion. Credit's given where credit's do, and vice versa. The only reason you made this thread is to stick up for your hero...On a website dedicated to his work. We are the fans that buy the mangas, dvds, and even games. So i think after spending all that time, that i have a right to criticize him, and praise him as i want. and it benefits him to, to hear from the fans, and there response. He's a human, and he is going to make mistakes...But please stop acting like we're throwing rotten tomatoes at him. We all love his work. And i hate to tell you this, but you don't have to defend him here...Were all friends here. And at the end of the day, we all love Naruto. So chill out and mingle a little with your fellow fans. ^_^

[jsrhoden]

1. When was it ever suggested that we weren't aware that Kishi is in control of his own manga?

2. If there was no criticism on a website whose main purpose is to discuss Naruto, then things would be horribly boring, and the website would only consist of "Naruto is awesome!", "Kishi is a genius OMG!" and "I Love Naruto!" threads, which are actually really annoying.

3. Every manga has it's good points and bad points. In my eyes there is no such thing as a perfect manga. It would be childish just to move to another manga just because things turn out the way we didn't want them to - the war arc is annoying me to hell but i'm gonna stick around and see how the story ends. As stated above. we're all fans of the manga, we have a right to praise him when things go well, and criticize him when we're not too fond of his writing. I think we would all struggle to find a book today that doesn't have both positive and negative reviews.

4. I'm not really fond of people complaining about people complaining. Don't know, it just seems kinda pointless...

[KidGamer65]

If it weren't for criticism, nothing would ever be fixed, and nothing would ever get better. So its dumb to tell people to stop criticizing.

[Sasunarufan13]

If you publish something, you have to be ready for criticism. People will always find something to criticize. However there's a difference between constructive criticism (which is normally appreciated) and just criticism to give critic.

I admit that if people do nothing but criticize, I think they are better off then not reading it because that's generally a clue they don't enjoy the story anymore.

However, everyone has some point in a story that they don't like something or find something that contradicts something else in the story. If they enjoy it overall, then there's nothing wrong with giving criticism now and then (of course criticism on an English site won't do much when it comes to a Japanese serie but you get what I mean)

[JIRAIYA perv]

its a part of writing a manga (actually in doing anything, specially writing coz a writer is as good as his readers think he is). now what i don't understand is why do people care if someone criticizes the manga (kishi himself knows what he was up for when he decided to do it), this series is great but like many others has mistakes so you can't expect people to be like ..... "oh well its all good" and ignore the mistakes. this is not my favorite series but i can understand the people who love this and watch it mess up from time to time (its only natural for them to criticize kishi when he gets too boring, predictable or simply makes a mistake).

[htmwall]

i critisize him because it saddens me that the manga i liked so much has sunk to this level.

[Valen]

It his manga, he writes it how he wants to. People say that he should do this different and that different, and not making Obito Tobi, SHUT UP HES THE WRITER DONT LIKE IT READ ANOTHER MANGA

I think that he is doing a wonderful job at writing, every chapter lately is wonderful and full of action in my eyes

[minator93]

Because he is a fcking Manga artist

[Shadow Abyss]

Because as much as I'm a fan of his work I doesn't mean I have to kiss the ground he walks. There's nothing wrong with some criticism if it is constructive, sometimes it may even help the author to improve.
If an authour screws up that's the only way for him to know and not repeat the mistake.

[zinescience]

he writes it for others to read so if it is not good enough he deserves to be criticized.