[Discussion] I'm Curious About This So Help Me...[Official]

[Sonnelion]

Well gaara could only bend the sand previously because of the one tail's power,as said by dediera(mispelled).
[Picture N/A]
So then explain to me after it was extracted how can he possibly still bend it without using/using little chakra to bend/move his sand at will.Also the sand in his gourd still automatically protects him which makes no sense since it only did that due to the one tails.
WTHSo how in the hell is this stuff happening?!WTH

:rag:Stuff like this makes him seem smug even when fighting STOP CROSSING YOUR ARMS!!:rag:

Also not hating on gaara so don't be a douchebag:y just wondering also he is boss in most ways.

[final amaterasu]

http://www.mangareader.net/naruto/547/14

Thought it was already explained when Gaara fought his dad? It's his mother's power protecting him...

[Sonnelion]

That makes no since and that doesn't explain why he can control the sand dumb@ss.:rag::flaw:

[final amaterasu]

Okay jackass then y don't u cough up an explanation? you did ask why the sand in his gourd still protects him didn't you? The sand in his gourd is also infused with his own chakra :P oh yeah btw learn to spell and reply politely genius. Go do some research or atleast read through Naruto wiki and then make a thread.

[Sonnelion]

Okay jackass then y don't u cough up an explanation? you did ask why the sand in his gourd still protects him didn't you? The sand in his gourd is also infused with his own chakra :P oh yeah btw learn to spell and reply politely genius. Go do some research or atleast read through Naruto wiki and then make a thread.

You clearly didn'y know so might as well just let the thread stay unreplied to and since your explanation makes absolutely no sense how and the hell can his mom protecting him allow the sand to move without any handseals or anything?!
In short you're an idiot and further more...

[spatha]

You clearly didn'y know so might as well just let the thread stay unreplied to and since your explanation makes absolutely no sense how and the hell can his mom protecting him allow the sand to move without any handseals or anything?!
In short you're an idiot and further more...

be completely truthful...are you just trolling? It was clearly stated that the special sand in his gourd was infused with his mothers chakra and it protects him independently of his will or perception of danger around him (hence why it blocked naruto in the first season even though gaara was shocked that he could keep up with naruto). As for his general sand techniques, why do you assume gaara was totally pathetic without the one tails? his dad could control iron dust in a similar fashion without a tailed beast. It hasn't been explained in extreme detail, but it may be that sand manipulation takes less chakra than you would think and besides gaara must have a decent chakra pool to even contain the beast since every known seal used on a jinchuuriki feeds off their chakra to an extent...just because he doesn't have the almost infinite chakra pool like naruto doesn;t mean he is weak. Lastly, if you weren't trolling with your overly rude comments then a bit of advice...tone it down or you will quickly get a one way ticket to banville.

[final amaterasu]

? dude! I can't help it if you don't accept a fact that's right infront of you, read what Gaara's father said or better yet go read Naruto wiki about Gaara's power to control sand genius; Ignorant fool lol better yet here's a quote from Gaara's wiki page since your so lazy to find it yourself

"It was unknown at first whether or not Gaara's sand defence was still automatic as it was believed that Shukaku was the source of the defence. However, the Fourth Kazekage states that Gaara's mother, Karura, was the true source of the defence, as she truly did love him and vowed to always protect him"

- http://naruto.wikia.com/wiki/Gaara#Sand_Control

You want a better explanation? go ask Kishimoto; idiot :P

[Moe22]

Hahaha 30 seconds=made

[Moe22]

But seriously, it is Gaara's mom that's protecting him.

[xNiinJutsuu]

He's using his bankai...are you serious dude -_-?

[Frikid]

maybe shukaku told him the trick to cntrol sand?
nah its gaara's mother will whichstill protects him in form of moving sand.
it really touched me wen i read that gaara's mother wanted to protect him and what his father said earlier was a big lie

[Sonnelion]

? dude! I can't help it if you don't accept a fact that's right infront of you, read what Gaara's father said or better yet go read Naruto wiki about Gaara's power to control sand genius; Ignorant fool lol better yet here's a quote from Gaara's wiki page since your so lazy to find it yourself

- http://naruto.wikia.com/wiki/Gaara#Sand_Control

You want a better explanation? go ask Kishimoto; idiot :P

Hahaha 30 seconds=made

But seriously, it is Gaara's mom that's protecting him.

maybe shukaku told him the trick to cntrol sand?
nah its gaara's mother will whichstill protects him in form of moving sand.
it really touched me wen i read that gaara's mother wanted to protect him and what his father said earlier was a big lie

:lmao:

He's using his bankai...are you serious dude -_-?

[★Sir Derp Obito]

Well gaara could only bend the sand previously because of the one tail's power,as said by dediera(mispelled).
[Picture N/A]
So then explain to me after it was extracted how can he possibly still bend it without using/using little chakra to bend/move his sand at will.Also the sand in his gourd still automatically protects him which makes no sense since it only did that due to the one tails.
WTHSo how in the hell is this stuff happening?!WTH

:rag:Stuff like this makes him seem smug even when fighting STOP CROSSING YOUR ARMS!!:rag:

Also not hating on gaara so don't be a douchebag:y just wondering also he is boss in most ways.

MASSIVE SPOILER!: The sand is Gaara's mommy

[Sonnelion]

MASSIVE SPOILER!: The sand is Gaara's mommy

(o_0)?!WTH
So you mean to tell me all of the earth and the hidden sand village is composed of gaara's mother...

[BlueSky Garrett]

(o_0)?!WTH
So you mean to tell me all of the earth and the hidden sand village is composed of gaara's mother...

Man, you're wasting your time with these idiots, they'll take anything kishi writes without any questioning.
I completely agree with ya, it makes no sense whatsoever, but then again, the manga is full of plot holes and nonsense.

[★Sir Derp Obito]

(o_0)?!WTH
So you mean to tell me all of the earth and the hidden sand village is composed of gaara's mother...

No, as Gaara said he can spread his chakra infused sand with ordinary sand thus making any type of sand his weapon. He explained it to Lee during their fight with Kimimaro. the sand in the gourd is infused with his mommy's spirit.

[narutonish]

TBH I had this doubt too, it was never clearly explained.

I just accepted the plot no jutsu and moved on :/

[thegame]

Hmm, well it's a bit hard to explain, but Gaaras father sort of hinted that it actually came from her mothers love. Gaara is a rather special case, cause he had the Sanbi sealed, before he was born. This could make her mother get a lot of its chakra as well, which might have caused her death, but perhaps she sealed her own chakra in gaara or something through love. I mean baby and mother are connected in every way before the child is born, so it would only make sense if that goes for chakra as well. So Gaara probably has some of the Sanbis chakra with his own, meaning extracting it didn't remove it all, since it seemed like his mothers chakra.

[TheWillofFire]

It makes perfect sense.

Gaaras moms power is the power Gaara wields not the one tails.
Deidara said that but he doesnt know about his mom, they all assume it was the one tails, even Gaaras Dad.

So stop pretending it is an inconsistent plot hole or something because it makes perfect sense, just how Narutos Dad and Mom were able to help Naruto conquer Kurama.

[★General.]

Smh
Its rather obvious. His mother chakra is inside Gaaras sand. Not a plot hole. His mom spirit is set on earth to protect gaara.

[Sonnelion]

No logic behind some of your answers.

[TheWillofFire]

I would be happy to follow you through my logic

But I am not understanding your logic because your logic seems to be gaaras ultimate defense coming from the one tails, which is false..

[Sonnelion]

I would be happy to follow you through my logic

But I am not understanding your logic because your logic seems to be gaaras ultimate defense coming from the one tails, which is false..

How is it false when they said it in the manga that it stemed from the shukaku/one-tail so tell me or explain to me rather how my logic doesn't make sense...?:P

[TheWillofFire]

How is it false when they said it in the manga that it stemed from the shukaku/one-tail so tell me or explain to me rather how my logic doesn't make sense...?:P

The manga stated it stemed from the one tails, and then it stated it was never the one tails, rather gaaras mom, as shown to you on the manga page on post #2

So it is safe and logical to discard the idea of it stemming from the one tails, and rather stemming from the chakra of garaas mom

[Rikud0 Sennin]

How is it false when they said it in the manga that it stemed from the shukaku/one-tail so tell me or explain to me rather how my logic doesn't make sense...?:P

It has always been hinted at... During Garra's transformation at the Chuunin Exams, he calls the beast "Mother".

Garra's Father hinted that it actually came from his mothers love.

Take a look at how Garra's mother died. She turned to sand after a ritual, soon after she gave birth to her son.
The only thing that the One Tail gave him was insomnia, and a bad attitude. Whenever he gave Garra some power, it was to try to break free from control. Which did happen vs. Naruto and Cheif toad.


Think about it... When has a TB ever protected a jinjuriki in the 1st part? They didn't. Whenever Naruto got the TB cloak, it was because he had the Dark Naruto inside of him. It was because his emotions were compromised, and the Dark Naruto let in the beasts chakra. (against sasuke and zabuza, NOT against garra bc he trained on how to consciously use that particular chakra.)

Garra can control the sand the same way his father can control it. When the sand has a mind of its own, its his mother. The trick is the ritual. That made the mother into a sand spirit.