The truth about the Mangekyo Sharingan!

[Madara Uchiha]

I have just thought of a theory to how u "really" obtain the MS.
So u all heard that itachi said the only way to obtain MS was to kill ur best friend right, well that may not be true. We only heard Itachi say this. Based on our facts kakashi, madara, madara's brother, and sasuke's MS(If he really has one) were all obtained through a different way. Does this mean that itachi lied? When sauske asked his father about sharingan his father told him that there are certain "conditions" but he never said what they were making us think that what itachi said is true. But why would itachi say that to sasuke? Itachi was incredibly smart so he basically knew almost evrything that would happen. At the time, did he know sasuke and naruto would become best friends? If he did then this supports the idea that itachi lied and wanted sasuke to think that killing ur best friend was the only way. He did this to tempt sasuke to eventually kill naruto to destroy madara's plans of getting the kyuubi. What do u guys think? :D Itachi was a more of a genius then we already know himt to be of this is true.:D:D:D Do u thin this is accurate or not?:D

Basically, there is another way to obtain MS but what?

~Madara Uchiha~

[Sakumo Hatake]

Yes i do

[XSasuke UchihaX]

I also agree with you that Itachi is smart and it does look accurate.

[Madara Uchiha]

:D!!!WooT!!!!:D

[Ero sennin]

interesting thought. madra would never be able to return to full power if he the fox dies. maybe so itachi could stand a chance against him.

[Madara Uchiha]

Yep, but the real question is how do u really obtain MS?

[Miggy69]

it sounds great and all and itachi really was a genius but how would he know about naruto and sasuke becoming best friends that is pure fate unless someone tells me that everything that happened to naruto and sasuke after the death of the uchicha clan was a set up team 7 was a set up and all the trials were set up. sorry but i dont agree with that

[Madara Uchiha]

yeah, thats the only problem. But, i still think that itachi wouldve figured that out cuz look at what he's already done. Evry single detail of his plan fell into place. He is a complete genius!! So it is entirely possible.

[noyoyo]

While this isn't preposterous, I don't think it's true.

Itatchi may have been smart, but he couldn't see the future...as far as we know...

*cue ominous music*

[*Black*]

OMG thats crazy .how'd you come up with that.............

[Madara Uchiha]

Took me like 5 minuites of thinking.:D

[MinatoNaruto]

Yea i feel you on this Madara

[Nexus]

I did put yes up there only because u and some other friends of mine did, but that theory is....

[ToadSageJiraiya]

good i like it

[MS_Evolution]

i think ima jump on the bandwagon and agree

[YaminoSoul]

good points madara:D

[Miggy69]

so itachi knew naruto and sasuke will become best friends that seems impossible unless he told the 3rd hokage to put them in the same team and send them on the mission to the land of waves and have them battle haku and become good friends

[MS_Evolution]

i very much doubt it
he may have been smart but dats just seeing into the future more or less

[mihcom]

I think you obtain MS if someone close to you dies:

1. Madara and his broher lived in era of war so it's very probable that someone close to them died
2. Itachi obtained MS by killing his best friend
3. Sasuke killed Itachi and gained MS (but at the same time Itachi gave him his doujutsu so he gained PMS or at least an advanced form of MS)

the only one who obtained MS in a different way is kakashi and I think he obtained it by using his favorite sharingan technique: he copied Itachi's MS, I mean think about it he awakened is MS AFTER his fight with Itachi

like it was said in another thread (can't remember which one) maybe I tachi told sasuke to kill his best friend because it was a the most basic way of obtaining MS

[MS_Evolution]

yeh seems believable

[Rokudou Sennin]

I think to really obtain it you have to steel someones eyes.

[MS_Evolution]

that seems too unlikely

[Bancie]

While this isn't preposterous, I don't think it's true.

Itatchi may have been smart, but he couldn't see the future...as far as we know...

*cue ominous music*

Agreed. (=

The basic way to get the MS is to have someone close to you die.
Sasuke because of Itachi's death, Kakashi because of Obito's death (although unconfirmed since he had it for a long time), and Itachi got his because of Shisui's death.

It doesn't necessarily have to be you killing your best friend, it just has to be someone that's really important to you dying (perhaps in front of your eyes).

If Sasuke kills his best friend (as Itachi said), it'd fulfill the above conditions and he'd obtain MS. Itachi just gave him a way to get it, which fulfills the conditions without actually telling him the conditions.

There are possibly other ways to get it, although unlikely.


(=

[Nanashi]

Can't flaw your logic there Spooky :o

[master of the sharingan]

have yall noticed that madara, sasuke, itachi, and kakshi all have different mangekyou sharingans....