Lord of the rings or Harry Potter

[KattyRedCloud1706]

What she says. You're comparing HP which is, how you twist or turn it, just to amuse people with a story that tries blend in to the normal world, which is completely impossible.

While LOTR is a completely different history. Hp was written almost on a whim in a relatively short time. Tolkien worked his entire life on the history of LOTR. He made a history of more than 10 000 years with its own languages, cities, myths, legends, songs etc.

HP is fun to read and easier to understand than LOTR and if you just want to read, yes then you should read HP. However beyond all doubt LOTR is better. To put it simple HP is down to earth, while LOTR has an almost divine status.

couldnt have said it myself

[adams30]

i read both and i appreciate harry potter over lord of the ring(which is better as movie)

[missing]

lord of the rings

[Wherewolf]

Which do you prefer ? I just want to check which is the better book acording to narutobase members . Thanks for reading my post

I prefer Harry Potter as I could actually connect with Rowling's work but they shouldn't be compared imo. I still like LOTR movies to HP movies >.>

[Oblivion]

if i ever was forced to read or watch one of those two, i'd choose Lord of the rings!

[katsagu]

Harry potter

[darknesscreater]

Lord of the Rings PWNS Harry Potter
the books are better than the movie, so read the books, dont watch the movie

[KakashiLover]

I prefer Harry Potte, but to be honest, I never read the LotR books, so maybe after I have done I can say which one is better

[Algalon]

I prefer Harry Potte, but to be honest, I never read the LotR books, so maybe after I have done I can say which one is better

HP is incomparable to LoTR it just cant compete with the Trilogy

[leliana]

Lord of the Rings is epic, I reread it a few times. Only read the first two books of Harry Potter then got bored.

[Stewie Griffin]

LoTR here

[kawaii]

Harry Potter