Re: Does the Sharingan copy jutsu, or just Kakashi?
Why is everyone trying to argue with me about a point, and only confirming what I JUST said?
By ''Sharingan doesn't give you the ability to use the technique'', I'm saying that witnessing a jutsu firsthand, such as Lee's Taijutsu, does not magically grant the Sharingan bearer the ability to properly mould the chakra, nor does it magically grant the physical prowess required for those techniques. MY EXAMPLE for THAT case was Lee's taijutsu. For everything you've attempted to counter, Hammy in all these threads, you've only proven myself correct. I think you did get me on something though.. I'd have to look.
Basically, what I just said was.. Sasuke can ''learn how'' to copy Lee's taijutsu via his Sharingan.. but it doesn't mean he has the physical speed and power to do so.. hence why he underwent speed training. I applied this same logic to ninjutsu. Ninjas have to TRAIN to learn elemental affinities. Just as they would to train their physical bodies for taijutsu. Under the same method of logic (Which, oddly enough Hammy, my posts appear abundant with), then A Sharingan user, who knows Wind and Water elemental release.. can ''know'' how to use a Fire Elemental release he sees, but not have the capability, the training, what have you (The ''speed'' factor of Sasuke w/ Lee Taijutsu), to actually mold the chakra for the technique correctly.
Hammy, the Sharingan cannot copy EVERY jutsu and EVERY taijutsu barring the Jyuken. There's quite a bit it's can't copy. Hyoton, Mokuton, Gaara's Sand, Kimimaro's Shikotsumyaku(sp?), Souma no Kou. Basically kekkei genkai, or jinchuuriki-based skills.. Being as it appears you've at least done some research for Naruto though, I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you simply forgot.
Itachi did not -give- Sasuke all of his techniques. Itachi used a specific jutsu (go look it up) to implant his own Amaterasu into Sasuke's eye, to activate upon seeing Madara's face. That's why Itachi's M. Sharingan appears during that event, and not Sasuke's own (which shows up later). After that, Sasuke is never seen using Amaterasu with Itachi's MS pattern again, as far as I can recall. Also, Sasuke uses Tsukuyomi with the opposing eye as Itachi would, same with Amaterasu. Similarly, Sasuke also differs from Itachi in the formation of his Susanoo, which intrinsically looks far more vengeful and ''evil'' than Itachi's did. I fail to see how this translates into Itachi giving Sasuke his MS powers.
Shisui's eye was never stated to be a Mangekyo, and if it was then Danzo would've expressed it, unless there's hidden traits of the Sharingan not yet revealed. It is assumed that those effects were simply Shisui's own. But if we're talking about how everyone has a unique Sharingan ability, I find it odd how Kirigakure makes note of the fact that they find the effects of Shisui's eye to be similar to what they believed possessed the Mizukage.. whom was under Madara's control.
As for Madara/Kakashi, I was making a connection and saying how interesting it was that both Madara and Kakashi possess similar (Time/Space oriented) Mangekyo abilities.
Now, at the risk of sounding like an *******.... care to try again?