Manga Coloring Contest [13] VOTING

[Transparent]

Welcome to this month's Voting thread of the Manga Coloring Contest

Vote with your own opinion. Don't listen to what ppl are saying in the comments Vote for what u think took the most skills to do etc.

All contestants chose their own panel to color. It could be either a regular manga panel, or a lineart that someone made. Either way, the contestants have sent me the originals as well, so that you can judge whether it took skills or not to fulfill the job.

The rules are simple:
1. Do not vote for yourself.
3. Voting with multiple accounts is strictly forbidden
4. Don't tell others to vote for you, or to not vote for a specific entry! (
5. Don't flame, argue, or any form of mistreatment towards the voters, the entries, or the artists in question. I do not want any problems to happen that might ruin this competition.
6. Vote for the best entry and not the one people say is the best. Your opinion matters!
7. Please comment if you have an opinion about the entries or the contest. Just don't break the flaming rules.

If any of the rules 1,2 and 3 are violated, you will be disqualified and maybe banned from the next comp! (We will know if you do)

The Voting thread will be running till the end of the 31st of Oct (1 week) and I wish everyone good luck in the voting!:D The winner will receive a medal as usual.

Thank you all for joining this month's contest!

Entry 1:

Entry 2:

Entry 3:

Entry 4:

Entry 5:

[-Tauburn-]

Entry 4 gets my vote
very nice

[Mina..]

I didn't finish on time, again. ~_~
4 would be my vote if it wasn't so blury.

[Transparent]

I didn't finish on time, again. ~_~
4 would be my vote if it wasn't so blury.

better luck next time then ;D
I agree, too blurry

[Faith]

5th get my vote :
4th quite blur ~ ^^
nice job everyone :D

[Transparent]

5th get my vote :
4th quite blur ~ ^^
nice job everyone :D

you forgot to vote in the poll..

[BAN_KAI]

entry 4 all the way, the hair is awesome

[★Lord of Kaos]

none of them are over 9000?!?! ur scanner must be maltfunctioning

[Raiden..]

Nice job every1
I voted for entry 1, I loved the flames, they look awesome. It was hard to choose.

[~Cross Marian~]

I love how simple entry one is and top of that those flames which turn it to an another level. My second pick of choose would be entry 4 but as many said, It's a bit too blurry >_<

[Shuusai]

Entry 4 gets my vote
very nice

entry 4 all the way, the hair is awesome

People are so freakin Blind. Its blurry and its not of the coolness of the picture but it is of the Color and stuff.
Anyway First one gets my vote those flames....

[BAN_KAI]

People are so freakin Blind. Its blurry and its not of the coolness of the picture but it is of the Color and stuff.
Anyway First one gets my vote those flames....

rofl you are saying people are blind but you voted for entry 1 :confused: actually i hate entry 1, thats a 2 min job, only base colors and just 1 shade, its not important that entry 4 is blured, i can still see how good it is, this is the reason i never liked this contest

[~Racher~]

rofl you are saying people are blind but you voted for entry 1 :confused: actually i hate entry 1, thats a 2 min job, only base colors and just 1 shade, its not important that entry 4 is blured, i can still see how good it is, this is the reason i never liked this contest

I totally agree,with this i don't know how it has the most votes,no1 like you said has nothing in it except a fire ball with some fire effects on the legs and simple base colours...no work..exactly a 2 min job.

[Sonne]

I totally agree,with this i don't know how it has the most votes,no1 like you said has nothing in it except a fire ball with some fire effects on the legs and simple base colours...no work..exactly a 2 min job.

Simplicity can sometimes be better.

[~Racher~]

Simplicity can sometimes be better.

surely that's your opinion.My opinion totally differs from that,simplicity is indeed better sometimes but this colouring is too simple,no hard work.. it has no creativity just a lineart with base colours,nothing it looks awful without any shading....if the guy/gal had even shaded it too some extent or made a background with his/her imagination,it would have been good,but this colouring is seriously lame in comparison to the other colorings in the competition which do have some shading and creativity with colouring.But that is wholly my opinion.I am no artist but too me it looks totally deplorable.

[Transparent]

Who would like some gypsy tears?:b

[yourfaceishideous]

Who would like some gypsy tears?:b

I would? o.O

[yourfaceishideous]

surely that's your opinion.My opinion totally differs from that,simplicity is indeed better sometimes but this colouring is too simple,no hard work.. it has no creativity just a lineart with base colours,nothing it looks awful without any shading....if the guy/gal had even shaded it too some extent or made a background with his/her imagination,it would have been good,but this colouring is seriously lame in comparison to the other colorings in the competition which do have some shading and creativity with colouring.But that is wholly my opinion.I am no artist but too me it looks totally deplorable.

I completely agree with this. :] Though, I did vote for number one. But I have my reasons. Which I don't feel like exploiting because I don't want to be mean to other members in the contest. And I hope though won't be mean to the one I submitted into the contest. Number for does have some great shading, and it is blurry. Though that shouldn't take away from people's votes. A great editing job. I'm stunned they could edit that well. Ha! It's kind of unbelievable, really. Anyone, number one is as you said a 2 minutes job indeed. The flames just a detail to the work. Simple. But perhaps they came into this contest with moderate skills, and doesn't really know how to shade yet, don't bag on he/she that bad. It's cute, and simple. But, if I am to be honest, it's weird that it's got a lot of votes for being so simple. I would think 5 and 4 would be up a bit higher in the votes. At least 5 anyway. It looks like it really took a while. It's pretty good, nonetheless. Well, that's my little say about this. :D

[Vitality4Life]

Did you participate this month yourfaceishideous?

[Bisma]

Entry third gets my vote.

[Savior..]

Number four says mangastream, dont think he made it :\

[Transparent]

Number four says mangastream, dont think he made it :\

mangstream is just the website that published the manga page and put their watermark on the image. The artist of nr 4 didn't make the picture, he/she just colored the lineart

[yourfaceishideous]

Did you participate this month yourfaceishideous?

I did indeed submit. :]

[Vitality4Life]

It would be better for atleast to have 1st to 3rd place again. And have em all get medals?

[..Chill.. Klitz]

*sigh* I knew that blur was suspicious...

http://browse.deviantart.com/?q=aize...et=24#/d2yfsr0



Edit:
Number 5 got my Vote, there's potential there.