Re: Top 5 Elite QB's as of right now!
Did you see the games both had yesterday? They each threw 3 interceptions, if you would have said ryan a week ago, maybe, but definitely not now. As for alex smith, HA! That is all, I wouldn't put him top 10 atm, he has an amazing running game, and one of the best receiving squads in football, if he was a top 5 QB the niners would be invincible.
Originally Posted by Cobra73
Peyton is in the decline of his career, he is talking about right now.
Originally Posted by Typhon
5. Drew brees
Originally Posted by Forbidden Technique
If he doesn't start playing more like drew brees, and winning football games, ben rothlinsberger is gonna make this list ahead of him.
4. Peyton Manning
Even on the bad side of his career, need I say more?
3. Tom brady
Two years ago I would've put brady number 1 on this list(yes, even after rodgers had that amazing run of like, 16 games without an INT), however, the giants really exposed brady's weakness, if you hit him, really shake him up, even a secondary that an average QB should be able to pick apart, he can't do squat. They showed that twice.
2. Aaron Rodgers
Yes, he threw for 6 TDs last night, yes he was amazing last year, where has he been this year up until last night? He has to continue to do that before he re-earns his #1 spot.
1. Eli Manning
What more does this guy have to do to prove he is the current best QB in the NFL? Over the last 5 years he has the most superbowls, he's grown the most as a QB, and at this point he is the guy I would want with 2 minutes to go, needing a drive to tie/win the game, he is a fourth quarter wonder(yeah, they lost to the eagles, eli still led a drive that should've won the game, he can't do everything, kickers gotta kick), he doesn't make those bad decisions, he has 5 INTs this year, 3 were in the first half of the Tampa Bay game, he went on to throw for 510 yards and lead a comeback win. This guy, currently, is footballs top QB, I don't think that can really be argued. Behind all the Breese/Brady breaking marino's reacord and all, Eli threw for 67 yards shy of 5,000, that goes a little unnoticed by some.