Re: truth or lie about nagato's rinnegan
I realy like the fact that people are devided over this poll, 17lie vs 20true and I like the theory's about it being true aswell
here is my vision on what some people said:
like many people said, it might be possible that he helped nagato to get the rinnegan activated without nagato knowing it, like people said, by controling his environment. I myself see some possibility in that theory and would be willing to accept it as a possible option.
others speak of madara transplanting the rinnegan to nagato during the first blackout, I see just 1 flaw in that, and it's on the page that I gave in my first post in this thread. nagato's rinnegan was active befor he passed out while he was charging those shinobi, meaning that if madara ever transplanted them to nagato he must have done it before this moment.
I'm not saying that transplanting is not an option, all I'm saying is that it was done before all the flashbacks we saw from nagato's childhood with his parrents.
personaly I'm still thinking madara was lying, I don't know to what purpose, but he has been lying a lot in this manga, one that I can remember is that he told a lie to sasuke when he said that the 9tails attack on konoha was a natural occurance and that he had nothing to do with it. while both naruto's father and mother said different things and that we clearly got to see madara summon the 9tails into konoha.
not to mention, he is the badguy, aren't bad guys supposed to do things that are not honorable, like lying theyr teeth off
but I love the response I'm getting to this discusion, it's all been solid, thanks a lot guys, keep it going