Re: How did madara give rinnegan to nagato???
My First Post!
BTW I've only watched the cartoon.
1. I think when Madara said he Gave Nagato the eyes, that it is not physically gave, but he was a factor. To the argument that he could not be the father, it's easy to get around. He could have been the father and left Nagato in a basket on their porch...so to speak. Adoption is easy to justify. I think madara simply tracked the lineage of the Uzumaki. On one hand the Rinnegan may simply pop up when needed..... but only in a Uzumaki. And I don't thnk Madara is the darkness that would have brought it. Not for Nagato. For him, it was just a time of war. And that created the need, if anything. We are going back over twenty years, since Nagato was trained before Minato, which was before Minato was Hokage and Madara made his return to Konoha.
I don't think it takes a Sharingan to create the Rinnegan. Also, no one ever mentions it, but I've seen the Rinnegan eyes before. Remember when that group tried to kill naruto and Yamato and whoever else. They had some earth jutsu users who created a maze. A girl who could steal your life with a kiss, and the other girl had the Rinnegan eyes. She could use all the elements, but her hair was her weakness. She ended up being a flying wig with Rinnegan eyes. That couldn't be such a careless mistake right?
2. Also, Madara mentioned that he needed Nagato's resurrection technique for himself. I was under the impression that his body would have been restored. But it was wasted on Konoha. And yet, why would he have waited for later? If pain has the technique to heal his body, and the eyes he wants, why wait? Just kill him and get it done, why leave anything to chance in the future. Especially once most of the Tailed beasts have been captured.
And why would he have always planned to take the Rinnegan, if he needed the eternal mangekyou to bounce tsukoyomi off the moon. Plus once he does that, he wins. No need for Rinnegan, right?